So which is the best for us?

I am trying to settle on an Arabic curriculum. Maybe you can help me figure out the answer by giving your input. The following are the viable options I have found:

Gateway to Arabic

Includes IS has some resources simple audio

Need to supplement oral dull apearance

ArEg
 

Audio simple interesting

Have to supplement writing Have to have web

 

Learn NC

Is actual etext book has videos aimed at conversation moderately simple

Have to have web geared towards High Schoolers lots of vocabulary  to supplement written

ArabicTutor


 

Nice GUI Simple has audio has writing exercises

On PC only have to supplement oral no grammar (may not be a bad thing though)

Modern Written Arabic (FBI)

Simple Need to supplement oral and written

Fewer resources lots of vocabulary vocabulary aimed at FBI

 

Madina

Many resources Familiarity with text Have good supplements available Don't need web has some child aimed resources Aimed at adults many vocabulary words Need to supplement oral and written